According to the ATF database, there are 5 registered FFLs in Cato, New York.
11371 SOUTH STCATO, NY, 13033
1782 STATE RT 370 WESTCATO, NY, 13033
12346 POPLE RDCATO, NY, 13033
11393 MISTY MEADOWS DRCATO, NY, 13033
2849 STOCKWELL RDCATO, NY, 130330000